Top Keeper League Targets

[shortsavage]

Just thought I would do a list of my top 10 keeper league targets for 2004+. What ten guys would you most like to have on a keeper league team, if you were to start the league in 2004?

1. Albert Pujols
2. Alex Rodriguez
3. Carlos Beltran
4. Vladimir Guerrero
5. Eric Gagne
6. Lance Berkman
7. Mark Prior
8. Miguel Tejada
9. Roy Halladay
10. Nomar Garciaparra

[DK]

Soriano, Maggs, Beckett

[Madison]

Tejada/Berkman/Gagne would not be in my top 10.

I'd put Helton and Pedro in there for starters.

I'm always tinkering with my rankings, but the three I would move out wouldn't crack my top 10.

[Guest]

Tejada/Berkman/Gagne would not be in my top 10.

They wouldn't be in mine either. I'd also add Helton in there along with Maggs.

[blankman]

That was me above ^

[DK]

Yes, of course, helton and pedro as well

[Madison]

That was me above ^

Maggs is always floating right there around #10 for me. There's 4 or 5 guys that are right around the bubble for the last one or two spots in my top 10.

Tejada/Berman/Gagne are not close to that bubble.

[shortsavage]

Who would you guys call the top keeper league catcher?

My draft sheet is currently showing Pudge, who is slightly higher than Posada.

Would it be wise to go with a proven guy like Pudge, or are Martinez and Mauer going to be the catcher of the future?

[HOOTIE]

Tejada/Berkman/Gagne would not be in my top 10.

I'd put Helton and Pedro in there for starters.

Agreed. Pedro, Helton, and Soriano replace those 3.

[HOOTIE]

Who would you guys call the top keeper league catcher?

My draft sheet is currently showing Pudge, who is slightly higher than Posada.

Would it be wise to go with a proven guy like Pudge, or are Martinez and Mauer going to be the catcher of the future?

Pudge or Posada. Pretty close. Maybe a slight edge to Posada because of park, and the huge amount of games catching Pudge has on knees. Mauer is the c of future, but i wouldnt keep him over the current big guys.