Jason Botts or Jeff Mathis??

[sliders51]

I can only keep one...which one will give me more point next year? I dont care about positions they play...which should I keep?

[FalcoAtL]

Botts for sure. Mathis has Napoli and Molina to compete with and still hasn't earned a legitimate role with the big league club. Botts, although he has not done a whole lot either, almost is guaranteed to get a decent amount of at bats this year at DH from what I have heard.

[Bostonboy]

it's really a tough call. mathis has more potential in the long run, but is pretty much blocked this year.
botts will get some ab's, but at whose expense? lofton and cat need to get their ab's, and cruz had a fine winter ball season.

[FalcoAtL]

it's really a tough call. mathis has more potential in the long run, but is pretty much blocked this year.
botts will get some ab's, but at whose expense? lofton and cat need to get their ab's, and cruz had a fine winter ball season.

Agreed Mathis has more potential, but he wants to know who will have a bigger impact THIS season. Without a doubt I think Botts will.

Also I don't think that OFers will effect how much playing time Botts will get. I think he will get a decent amount of ABs at DH not OF.

[sLim]

personally...all ive really heard about is mathis' potential defensively...havent heard much about his offensive potential...from a fantasy perspective...i would go with botts...