My Top 40 SP 2007 rankings

[giants8307]

I agr, it is slim pickings. Good nws is that so many young guys in middl groups - I think 5 mor acs will arriv by 2008.

5 more ACS? Noooooo!

hahahaha!

[rotoquest]

Also, I can't believe we all neglected Dontrel Willis. He should definitely be on there, imo.

You are absolutely right. I don't know what was worse, my brainfart not putting him on there originally, or 25 posts before someone caught it. Thanks.

Honestly, it took me reading through the Sporting News expert mock to catch it.

I guess those things are useful for something after all.

I put willis at 22 on the list and bumped everyone else down one, so penny is now off the top 40.

[bellings]

I have to agree with the placement of Harden, Felix, and Prior on the "expert" list. All of them have insane talent. Prior has proven that he just plain cannot be trusted. But with Harden and Felix, they are just too good to pass up around ~30.

[Tommy John]

How about Hamels? Seems he should most likely fit in somewhere.

[billybedlam]

i may be crazy but the D-train is a top 30 pithcer on every sight that is predicting top 40 pitchers. perhaps he was overlooked? the guy gets 1 dwi and is banished off the list. wheres the love for dontrelle? he's better than half that list. perhaps it was an oversight. if not i'm in trouble i just traded for him.

[rotoquest]

i may be crazy but the D-train is a top 30 pithcer on every sight that is predicting top 40 pitchers. perhaps he was overlooked? the guy gets 1 dwi and is banished off the list. wheres the love for dontrelle? he's better than half that list. perhaps it was an oversight. if not i'm in trouble i just traded for him.

Look 3 threads above your post:
"I put willis at 22 on the list and bumped everyone else down one, so penny is now off the top 40."

[rotoquest]

Made a few adjustments again adding Willis & Hamels. Please share your thoughts.

01. Santana
02. Carpenter
03. Oswalt
04. Webb
05. Halladay
06. Zambrano
07. Peavy
08. Smoltz
09. Lackey
10. Sabathia
11. Sheets
12. Schilling
13. Harang
14. Bonderman
15. Haren
16. Schmidt
17. Myers
18. Lowe
19. Mussina
20. Arroyo
21. Zito
22. Willis
23. Cain
24. Young C
25. Kazmir
26. Harden
27. Bedard
28. Burnett
29. Matsuzaka
30. Johnson R
31. Hamels
32. Weaver Jered
33. Verlander
34. Santana E
35. Wang
36. Bush
37. Capuano
38. Johnson J
39. Garcia
40. Olsen

[billybedlam]

i like the list, but i think mussina, lowe, and zito are too high. also randy johnson should be #40 if he's lucky. matt cain should be ahead of lowe and mussina, i know mussina had a good year , but he's going to get lit up this year. cain will be a stud. also felix hernandez is going to be a top 20 pitcher. i know this list is more based on last years stats, but if you go by potential for thiss year it would be a little different. if you have time, try and make up a list of the top 40 at the end of 2007. guys like johnson and mussina will get bumped by guys like hamels, cain, sowers, lowry ect...

[Yoda]

tough to take a list seriously that omits Hamels in top 60 among SPs.

[rotoquest]

tough to take a list seriously that omits Hamels in top 60 among SPs.

I don't understand your thread. It's 40 SP, and Hamels is #31.