role models 7.5/10 first viewing, meh second.
I Love You Man, 8 (first viewing)
Watchmen (9) im a nerd.
Dark Knight (8)
Death Race (10) -- completely crappy, the 10 is of a different scale. The I had some beers and want some crap to watch scale.
X-Files I want to Believe (6.5)
Burn After Reading (8.5)
Lost Boys of Sudan (10)
Get Smart (5)
Hellboy 2 (no rating. Good, but "good is a stretch. entertaining for what it is, if I had to pick, I'd say quality 6)
Run Fatboy (I had it at 6, the lady has an 8)
Tropic Thunder (surprisingly funny, I'd go 7ish maybe more)
Mamma Mia (2) if you HAVE to watch a chick flick watch Definitely, Maybe
3:10 to Yuma (8ish, but I love westerns)