Rookie of the year?

[Transmogrifier]

agreed. ichiro got it, matsui should at least be eligible. he should win it as well, IMO.

I guess. However, Berroa's numbers are very, very good, too. So I look at it like MVP. I'd like to give the award to a team that made or nearly made the playoffs, though I don't think it's necessary.

Arod wins by default, this year, then.

So I'll only give it to "fake" rookies when there are no other deserving canidates. Hence Berroa.

[Brandaddy]

my vote would go to Berroa
and in the NL i would prolly give it to Webb.
but it hink willis will get it just cuz of all the hype around him and so forth.

[LCBOY]

By the current ML rules Matsui is a rookie.

[Madison]

By the current ML rules Matsui is a rookie.

I think we all agreed that Matsui does qualify for the ROY.

I thought the debate was should he qualify as a rookie?

[Guest]

Webb has had better overall stats then Willis, his record is not as impressive, but the main reason why Willis will win it is because of his impact on the Marlins. He is one of the main reasons they'll be playing in the postseason this year and that alone should merit the award to him.