I agree. The only thing with Duncan is I think with 450+ AB the league is gonna figure him out and he won't be on pace to hit 40+ HR like he did after the ASB. He'll get 30, sure, but he's still not the high OBP guy they need in front of Pujols ... at least not yet, maybe in a year or two. And that still leaves the other corner OF spot to be filled and there's no one in house who can do that yet, so you've got
to keep Edmonds so you're not looking for two middle of the order OF bats this winter.
Though I think they've proven this year that the regular season means squat if you get healthy and hot at the right time.