My Top 100

[FalcoAtL]

I bet you'll see Guzman on the cusp of or failing to make some pretty hightly regarded top 100 lists.

Not sure I understand why. He had a decent year.

[shortsavage]

Are you just looking at his PCL numbers?

[garf112]

Everyone has forgotten about Chris Lubanski... His eye got better at the plate, and I see a spike in power that will make him a .300-25 HR- 15 SB guy. He has to be in the top 100.

[FalcoAtL]

Ohhhh... I was looking at a site that only had his PCL numbers. Durham he hit .190 in 90 ABs, but is that enough of a slump to cause a top prospect to lose value completely? Its very possible that the trade to TB really caused him to lose his confidence or he may not have adjusted well. I fully expect him to bounce back though.

[FalcoAtL]

Everyone has forgotten about Chris Lubanski... His eye got better at the plate, and I see a spike in power that will make him a .300-25 HR- 15 SB guy. He has to be in the top 100.

Actually I didn't forget about him. Someone suggested I remove him. Although I'm not entirely sure he would be ahead of among OF prospects.

[garf112]

thought i had read through all of the posts... guess not

I see plenty of OFers he should be ahead of. Here's 4:
Drew Stubbs
Tyler Colvin
Ryan Sweeney
Anthony Webster

[FalcoAtL]

thought i had read through all of the posts... guess not

I see plenty of OFers he should be ahead of. Here's 4:
Drew Stubbs
Tyler Colvin
Ryan Sweeney
Anthony Webster

Done.

BTW Stubbs and Webster aren't even on the top 100.

[shortsavage]

Ohhhh... I was looking at a site that only had his PCL numbers. Durham he hit .190 in 90 ABs, but is that enough of a slump to cause a top prospect to lose value completely? Its very possible that the trade to TB really caused him to lose his confidence or he may not have adjusted well. I fully expect him to bounce back though.

The PCL is known as a hitter-friendly league, so maybe his International Leagues are a little more telling than you'd think. Also, Guzman has always been a guy who has gotten a pass because he is young for his level. I still think he'll become a major league starter at some point, but he's certainly not looking like someone who will be above-average.

My top 25 is reserved for future stars. My 26-50 is for pretty sure bets to become above-average regulars, 51-100 is average. There's no room for Guzman in my top 50 for sure.

Everyone has forgotten about Chris Lubanski... His eye got better at the plate, and I see a spike in power that will make him a .300-25 HR- 15 SB guy. He has to be in the top 100.

Actually I didn't forget about him. Someone suggested I remove him. Although I'm not entirely sure he would be ahead of among OF prospects.

Chris Lubanski does not have to be top 100. But he should at least receive some consideration for it.

[FalcoAtL]

What does everyone think of Eric Campbell? I really like his potential, but I'm not sure how he ranks among 3rd basemen at this point. He's still only at High A.

[FalcoAtL]

thought i had read through all of the posts... guess not

I see plenty of OFers he should be ahead of. Here's 4:
Drew Stubbs
Tyler Colvin
Ryan Sweeney
Anthony Webster

I'm not sure I like him more than Colvin, but I can def. see him being better than Sweeney.