great gretzky wrote:In this specific situation, I think the fairset thing to do would be to let you either keep one less player or assessing a middle round penalty for having two first roudners. Once you get into double digits, the draft penalty isn't enough, you can still participate in the key runs. shutting you out in a middle round might result in less steals or saves or something.
This is definitely a route that I will consider. I guess I'll just leave it up to the league vote to decide what the penalty is.
dannahann wrote:it's always best in a rules loophole conundrum, to hold yourself to even a higher standard than you'd hold your league. It sucks sometimes and hurts you competitively but YOU have to be the beacon of integrity or your league suffers
You're right on with my thinking here too. I would never consider making the rule effective this year unless it was my team that was involved. Anyone else and I'd be talking about grandfathering this year's teams in and making the rule effective going forward.