iftn wrote:how about intentionally walking a guy in the last game of a season so he cannot improve his batting average and thus take the batting title away from a teammate.
Yeah, that jumped out at me as well. That was the biggest joke I have ever seen on the baseball diamond...
You might think that's a joke, and I agree that it's very cheap, but I would also do that every time for a teammate if I was the pitcher (or coach).
wouldnt you want to EARN the batting title?
Come on...if you're even in the running for a batting title, you've earned it....it's not like somebody was letting someone else get a hit (that would be not earning it). This was prevention, plain and simple.
And frankly, no, I wouldn't care if some knucklehead didn't think I "earned" my batting title....I'd quietly remind him that I had a batting title and I didn't give a damn how it happened.
mak1277 wrote:I read a lot of posts on here that start out "Is it ethical to...", which kind of got me to thinking about ethics in fantasy baseball. Do we even need to consider "ethics", or can we simply focus on the rules of our leagues?
It's my position that anything within the rules is also, by nature, "ethical". Certain things may be consider "cheap" or "cheesy" ways to win, but isn't winning (within the rules) the only thing that matters?
I don't think ethics enter into the conversation at all...as long as your strategies and/or actions are within the rules, you shouldn't even think twice about it.
This kind of a question will differ from person to person. I personally don't agree with doing something that may be underhanded, cheap, or cheesy, whether there is a rule against it or not. I think you should play the game the way you think it should be played.
I know Generally, If I have to question whether it's right or wrong to do something, I don't do it. I would rather come in 2nd in a league and know that I played it in a way that I think keeps my integrity intact, then to do something underhanded and win it. I also don't think that winning is everything.
And I'll give a FBB example. A couple years ago, before Yahoo put in their idiot-proof system for add/drop, I made a mistake and accidentally dropped Soriano from my team. I posted a note explaining my mistake and asking the other managers to allow him to clear waivers and let me pick him back up. I agreed to accept any penalty the other managers and Commish thought was OK.
Now, by the rules, any other manager could have made a waiver claim and grabbed him.
Because the other managers in my league followed their ethics,rather than the rules, Soriano cleared waivers and I was able to reclaim him.
The penalty, of course, is that I am still ridiculed to this day for that mistake.