Ranking the 2006 Rookies in a Keeper League

[acsguitar]

1. Hamels
2. Hamels
3. Hamels
etc...

J/k

Hamels I think has really impressed so far this year.

Liriano has been the #1 pitcher but Hamels is nasty when he's on. Once he becomes a little more consistent good lord



Any mention of Troy Tuliowitski?

[tinfoilxtouch]

I put Cain as the #1 pitcher on my list, just because you have to factor injury into the equation.

[1337_Dude]

I might have missed him, but I didn't see Ryan Garko on the list if he qualifies. He has put up some nice numbers.

He's on there at 20.

[Yoda]

There are a lot of problems with your list but nice effort anyway. Seems like your ranking is mostly derived from what those rooks are putting up right now.

For instance, I am pretty comfortable in saying that Verlander, Cain, Billingsley will all be better than Papelbon.

Liriano, I can only imagine going down hill for him due to injuries. Anyway, off the top of my head:

Guys too low: Drew, Hermida, Marte, Quentin, Reyes, Pelfrey, Kemp, Hart

Guys too high: Liriano, Papelbon, Milledge, Weaver, Jacobs, Sanchez, Duncan, Bonser

[bigwords]

Move up: Zimmerman, Josh Johnson, Stephen Drew , Jonathan Broxton, Josh Barfield
Move down: Lastings Milledge, Chris B. Young, Mike Jacobs, Andy Marte, Chris Duncan, Boof Bonser, and maybe because of injuries, Francisco Liriano
Add: Brandon McCarthy

[GradysBaby13]

I'm just not as high on Andy Marte as I guess I should be. I am a big Indians fan, and honestly he just dosn't impress me that much.

Anyway anybody else here think the Diamondbacks & Marlins might be the best NL teams in a few years?

[Yoda]

I'm just not as high on Andy Marte as I guess I should be. I am a big Indians fan, and honestly he just dosn't impress me that much.

Anyway anybody else here think the Diamondbacks & Marlins might be the best NL teams in a few years?

Marte is very young. He has the tools to be very good in the near future.

D Backs will need some help in their rotation. Their offense will be ridiculous if Upton, Drew, Quentin, Jackson, Young, Gonzalez all become as good as advertised.