Chris Lubanski or Jacoby Ellsbury?

[ukjohn]

isn't this "fantasy baseball cafe"

i make my minors list according to fantasy value

[carter]

Lubanski doesn't project to be anybody too special

neither did the player in your sig, lol

[J35J]

Both are probably waiver wire guys throughout their careers, so i'm not concerned either way.


Jason

I'm just going to go back to this, if we're talking about fantasy purposes.



Jason

[bigken117]

Both are probably waiver wire guys throughout their careers, so i'm not concerned either way.


Jason

I'm just going to go back to this, if we're talking about fantasy purposes.



Jason

In 3 years -
I think someone leading off for the Red Sox won't find himself on the waiver wire for long, not compared to the #5 (at best) hitter for the Royals.

[J35J]

Both are probably waiver wire guys throughout their careers, so i'm not concerned either way.


Jason

I'm just going to go back to this, if we're talking about fantasy purposes.



Jason

In 3 years -
I think someone leading off for the Red Sox won't find himself on the waiver wire for long, not compared to the #5 (at best) hitter for the Royals.

Just because he is slated to be the lead off hitter doesn't mean he will stay there..... who's to say he pans out? or if he is good enough to even play full time what if he is only good enough to the be the #9 hitter....... Anyway, neither guy is really on my radar much for fantasy purposes.

Jason

[thedude]

Both are probably waiver wire guys throughout their careers, so i'm not concerned either way.


Jason

I'm just going to go back to this, if we're talking about fantasy purposes.



Jason

In 3 years -
I think someone leading off for the Red Sox won't find himself on the waiver wire for long, not compared to the #5 (at best) hitter for the Royals.

Just because he is slated to be the lead off hitter doesn't mean he will stay there..... who's to say he pans out? or if he is good enough to even play full time what if he is only good enough to the be the #9 hitter....... Anyway, neither guy is really on my radar much for fantasy purposes.

Jason

fast with great OBP, both things are good indicators of Major league success. Ellsbury will have a nice career.

[KOSTAS]

Ellsbury will very likely be leading off for the Red Sox by the start of 2008. Also struggled a little early on and then picked it up after july. Ellsbury (as any leadoff guy for the red sox) will have more value. In his prime look for .280-290 BA, a good amount of steals, and 100+ runs. Not a 1st round draft pick, but a solid player.

I very much doubt Ellsbury will be leading off for the Sox in 2008. It would take some very bad circumstances for that to happen.