Who would you keep?

[Scoots#5]

I am now looking at who i will keep - have to keep 7 guys. Who would you keep.

C - kendall
1b - helton
2b - ellis
3b - arod
ss - h ramirez
of - ca lee
of - ibanez
of - jd drew
util -baldelli
util - norton
DL - hafner

starters - pedro, schmidt, willis, randy, harden
relief - zumaya, papelbon, mcclung, saito, borowski, neshek

i have my theories, but would like a more broad range of ideas - will give mine after a few posts. thank you all.

[RynMan]

C - kendall
2b - ellis
of - jd drew
util - norton

harden
mcclung
borowski

Those guys.

[Mugrila]

C - kendall
2b - ellis
of - jd drew
util - norton

harden
mcclung
borowski

Those guys.

There's much more traffic in the draft/keeper forum so I think you'll get a much better response in there.

[go_jays_go]

There's much more traffic in the draft/keeper forum so I think you'll get a much better response in there.

Agreed.

I think your keepers would be..

Rodriguez
Ramirez
Lee
Martinez
Willis
Harden
Papelbon or Helton

Good luck.

[raiders_umpire]

3b - arod
ss - h ramirez
of - ca lee
DL - hafner
pedro
willis
harden

[mikekim2121]

Arod
Hanley
Carlos Lee
Hafner
Pedro
Papelbon
Helton

[prhood]

Keepers
A. Rodriguez
C. Lee
H. Ramirez
Hafner
T. Helton
D. Willis
Papelbon

[scotty_pod]

I am now looking at who i will keep - have to keep 7 guys. Who would you keep.

C - kendall
1b - helton
2b - ellis
3b - arod
ss - h ramirez
of - ca lee
of - ibanez
of - jd drew
util -baldelli
util - norton
DL - hafner

starters - pedro, schmidt, willis, randy, harden
relief - zumaya, papelbon, mcclung, saito, borowski, neshek

i have my theories, but would like a more broad range of ideas - will give mine after a few posts. thank you all.

Ramirez, Lee, Baldelli, Hafner, Willis, Harden, Papelbon

I think Arod's on a decline, and don't expect a bounce back year next year. Lee has been great for me all year long and is going to houston or wrigley next year which will be great for him. Baldelli is a risk, but one i'm willing to take for what he will do when healthy. Hafner is a no brainer. Schmidt and Pedro are in decline too.

I tend to take guys who are going to improve next year, rather than guys who will decline, so take my suggestions for what you will.

[tinfoilxtouch]

1. Arod
2. Hafner
3. HRam
4. Ca Lee
5. Harden
6. Papelbon
7. Pedro

You'd be crazy to keep Willis. He's been the 4th best starter on his own team this season. Furthermore, he might be the WORST starter on your team.

Help with mine? Link is in the sig.

[123inningplz]

ARod
Hafner
H. Ramirez
Baldelli
Harden
Papelbon
Pedro