Is Josh Johnson in the Cy Young Race?

[eftda]

Jason Schmidt anyone?

He doesn't have enough W's to get the voters attention IMO.

I don't see why wins should be in the mix. Clemens had 13 wins last year. If Schmidt is in the top 4 for K's and ERA then he should be in the final 3 for voting.

[ebrage]

Im thinking Billy Wagner.. My dream pick being zambrano

I agree!!

[DirtyKash]

Jason Schmidt anyone?

He doesn't have enough W's to get the voters attention IMO.

Wins will not be a factor for the NL Cy Young this year, as no one will get to 20.

[Pogotheostrich]

Jason Schmidt anyone?

He doesn't have enough W's to get the voters attention IMO.

I don't see why wins should be in the mix. Clemens had 13 wins last year. If Schmidt is in the top 4 for K's and ERA then he should be in the final 3 for voting.

Wins will not be a factor for the NL Cy Young this year, as no one will get to 20.

I wish W's weren't a factor but the voters have shown over and over that it is a big factor in their minds. And eftda, Clemens didn't win the Cy Young last year. Why would you use him of an example, when the reason he didn't win was the lack of W's?

[1337_Dude]

I think he has to be in the conversation, but I don't think he's the winner. I'd say Carlos Zambrano should win it.

[Mreater71]

I'm going with Smoltz. He would of had a lot more wins on his record if it wasn't for the Braves' pathetic bullpen that lost the games.

[Pstater71]

I'm going with Smoltz. He would of had a lot more wins on his record if it wasn't for the Braves' pathetic bullpen that lost the games.

Exactly!

[Broncmet724]

Yes, he should be considered. Especially if the Marlins win a wild card berth.