Havok1517 wrote:C Joe Mauer & Victor Martinez 1B Justin Morneau & Paul Konerko 2B Tadahito Iguchi & Luis Castillo 3B Mark Teahen & Joe Crede SS Carlos Guillen & Jhonny Peralta LF Scott Podsednik & Marcus Thames CF Tori Hunter & Grady Sizemore RF Jermaine Dye & Magglio Ordonez DH Travis Hafner & Jim Thome
SP Johan Santana SP Mark Buehrle SP C.C. Sabathia SP Justin Verlander SP Francisco Liriano LR Dennys Reyes LR Matt Thornton MR Fernando Rodney MR Juan Rincon SU Joel Zumaya SU Bobby Jenks CL Joe Nathan
VS.
C Jorge Posada & Ramon Hernandez 1B Kevin Youkilis & Lyle Overbay 2B Mark Loretta & Brian Roberts 3B Alex Rodriguez & Troy Glaus SS Derek Jeter & Miguel Tejada LF Manny Ramirez & Carl Crawford CF Vernon Wells & Johnny Damon RF Alex Rios & Bobby Abreu DH David Oritz & Jason Giambi
SP Roy Halladay SP Curt Schilling SP Josh Beckett SP Mike Mussina SP Scott Kazmir LR Scott Proctor LR Mike Myers MR Kyle Farnsworth MR Chris Ray SU B.J. Ryan SU Mariano Rivera CL Jon Papelbon
Okay, who wins????
I don't know anything about you, but I'm assuming you must be a BoSox fan. Anyone in their right mind would know that Rivera would be the closer, and Beckett (who kinda sucks) would not be the #3 SP.
And the East would win, that lineup would be too ridiculous. I think you can add Hideki Matsui to that lineup (who is almost healthy), when you have Kazmir in there, who is on the DL.
Havok1517 wrote:C Joe Mauer & Victor Martinez 1B Justin Morneau & Paul Konerko 2B Tadahito Iguchi & Luis Castillo 3B Mark Teahen & Joe Crede SS Carlos Guillen & Jhonny Peralta LF Scott Podsednik & Marcus Thames CF Tori Hunter & Grady Sizemore RF Jermaine Dye & Magglio Ordonez DH Travis Hafner & Jim Thome
SP Johan Santana SP Mark Buehrle SP C.C. Sabathia SP Justin Verlander SP Francisco Liriano LR Dennys Reyes LR Matt Thornton MR Fernando Rodney MR Juan Rincon SU Joel Zumaya SU Bobby Jenks CL Joe Nathan
VS.
C Jorge Posada & Ramon Hernandez 1B Kevin Youkilis & Lyle Overbay 2B Mark Loretta & Brian Roberts 3B Alex Rodriguez & Troy Glaus SS Derek Jeter & Miguel Tejada LF Manny Ramirez & Carl Crawford CF Vernon Wells & Johnny Damon RF Alex Rios & Bobby Abreu DH David Oritz & Jason Giambi
SP Roy Halladay SP Curt Schilling SP Josh Beckett SP Mike Mussina SP Scott Kazmir LR Scott Proctor LR Mike Myers MR Kyle Farnsworth MR Chris Ray SU B.J. Ryan SU Mariano Rivera CL Jon Papelbon
Okay, who wins????
I don't know anything about you, but I'm assuming you must be a BoSox fan. Anyone in their right mind would know that Rivera would be the closer, and Beckett (who kinda sucks) would not be the #3 SP.
And the East would win, that lineup would be too ridiculous. I think you can add Hideki Matsui to that lineup (who is almost healthy), when you have Kazmir in there, who is on the DL.
Actually I'm not a Red Sox fan or a Yankee fan. Sorry you're Yankee love blinds you from reality. I'm just going strickly by this year's numbers. Matsui and Shef have barely played this year and would not be on any All-Star team. Liriano is in the same boat that Kazmir is but both have great numbers this year. I'll repeat, Pap has had a better year as closer than Rivera has. Rivera is obviously the better player so far but an All-Star team goes by yearly stats and Pap beats all other closers.
Havok1517 wrote:C Joe Mauer & Victor Martinez 1B Justin Morneau & Paul Konerko 2B Tadahito Iguchi & Luis Castillo 3B Mark Teahen & Joe Crede SS Carlos Guillen & Jhonny Peralta LF Scott Podsednik & Marcus Thames CF Tori Hunter & Grady Sizemore RF Jermaine Dye & Magglio Ordonez DH Travis Hafner & Jim Thome
SP Johan Santana SP Mark Buehrle SP C.C. Sabathia SP Justin Verlander SP Francisco Liriano LR Dennys Reyes LR Matt Thornton MR Fernando Rodney MR Juan Rincon SU Joel Zumaya SU Bobby Jenks CL Joe Nathan
VS.
C Jorge Posada & Ramon Hernandez 1B Kevin Youkilis & Lyle Overbay 2B Mark Loretta & Brian Roberts 3B Alex Rodriguez & Troy Glaus SS Derek Jeter & Miguel Tejada LF Manny Ramirez & Carl Crawford CF Vernon Wells & Johnny Damon RF Alex Rios & Bobby Abreu DH David Oritz & Jason Giambi
SP Roy Halladay SP Curt Schilling SP Josh Beckett SP Mike Mussina SP Scott Kazmir LR Scott Proctor LR Mike Myers MR Kyle Farnsworth MR Chris Ray SU B.J. Ryan SU Mariano Rivera CL Jon Papelbon
Okay, who wins????
I don't know anything about you, but I'm assuming you must be a BoSox fan. Anyone in their right mind would know that Rivera would be the closer, and Beckett (who kinda sucks) would not be the #3 SP.
And the East would win, that lineup would be too ridiculous. I think you can add Hideki Matsui to that lineup (who is almost healthy), when you have Kazmir in there, who is on the DL.
Actually I'm not a Red Sox fan or a Yankee fan. Sorry you're Yankee love blinds you from reality. I'm just going strickly by this year's numbers. Matsui and Shef have barely played this year and would not be on any All-Star team. Liriano is in the same boat that Kazmir is but both have great numbers this year. I'll repeat, Pap has had a better year as closer than Rivera has. Rivera is obviously the better player so far but an All-Star team goes by yearly stats and Pap beats all other closers.
So if you are going by this year's numbers, why in the world would you include Josh Beckett??
BxBombers951 wrote:also, cano should be there instead of either roberts or loretta
No way, Cano has only played 89 games this season.
So? Cano is better then Loretta.
Maybe not roberts, but Loretta.
Both Loretta and Roberts have played more games and have contributed more fantasy-wise and in reality this year. If Cano had been healthy all year he'd probably have better numbers than Loretta. But he didn't and doesn't. Look it up before you automatically say I'm wrong.
Havok1517 wrote:C Joe Mauer & Victor Martinez 1B Justin Morneau & Paul Konerko 2B Tadahito Iguchi & Luis Castillo 3B Mark Teahen & Joe Crede SS Carlos Guillen & Jhonny Peralta LF Scott Podsednik & Marcus Thames CF Tori Hunter & Grady Sizemore RF Jermaine Dye & Magglio Ordonez DH Travis Hafner & Jim Thome
SP Johan Santana SP Mark Buehrle SP C.C. Sabathia SP Justin Verlander SP Francisco Liriano LR Dennys Reyes LR Matt Thornton MR Fernando Rodney MR Juan Rincon SU Joel Zumaya SU Bobby Jenks CL Joe Nathan
VS.
C Jorge Posada & Ramon Hernandez 1B Kevin Youkilis & Lyle Overbay 2B Mark Loretta & Brian Roberts 3B Alex Rodriguez & Troy Glaus SS Derek Jeter & Miguel Tejada LF Manny Ramirez & Carl Crawford CF Vernon Wells & Johnny Damon RF Alex Rios & Bobby Abreu DH David Oritz & Jason Giambi
SP Roy Halladay SP Curt Schilling SP Josh Beckett SP Mike Mussina SP Scott Kazmir LR Scott Proctor LR Mike Myers MR Kyle Farnsworth MR Chris Ray SU B.J. Ryan SU Mariano Rivera CL Jon Papelbon
Okay, who wins????
I don't know anything about you, but I'm assuming you must be a BoSox fan. Anyone in their right mind would know that Rivera would be the closer, and Beckett (who kinda sucks) would not be the #3 SP.
And the East would win, that lineup would be too ridiculous. I think you can add Hideki Matsui to that lineup (who is almost healthy), when you have Kazmir in there, who is on the DL.
Actually I'm not a Red Sox fan or a Yankee fan. Sorry you're Yankee love blinds you from reality. I'm just going strickly by this year's numbers. Matsui and Shef have barely played this year and would not be on any All-Star team. Liriano is in the same boat that Kazmir is but both have great numbers this year. I'll repeat, Pap has had a better year as closer than Rivera has. Rivera is obviously the better player so far but an All-Star team goes by yearly stats and Pap beats all other closers.
So if you are going by this year's numbers, why in the world would you include Josh Beckett??
He's been terrible this year.
Well who is a better starter than Beckett in the East that hasn't already been included? Johnson? Wang? Lilly? Bedard? Slim pickings if you ask me.
Havok1517 wrote:C Joe Mauer & Victor Martinez 1B Justin Morneau & Paul Konerko 2B Tadahito Iguchi & Luis Castillo 3B Mark Teahen & Joe Crede SS Carlos Guillen & Jhonny Peralta LF Scott Podsednik & Marcus Thames CF Tori Hunter & Grady Sizemore RF Jermaine Dye & Magglio Ordonez DH Travis Hafner & Jim Thome
SP Johan Santana SP Mark Buehrle SP C.C. Sabathia SP Justin Verlander SP Francisco Liriano LR Dennys Reyes LR Matt Thornton MR Fernando Rodney MR Juan Rincon SU Joel Zumaya SU Bobby Jenks CL Joe Nathan
VS.
C Jorge Posada & Ramon Hernandez 1B Kevin Youkilis & Lyle Overbay 2B Mark Loretta & Brian Roberts 3B Alex Rodriguez & Troy Glaus SS Derek Jeter & Miguel Tejada LF Manny Ramirez & Carl Crawford CF Vernon Wells & Johnny Damon RF Alex Rios & Bobby Abreu DH David Oritz & Jason Giambi
SP Roy Halladay SP Curt Schilling SP Josh Beckett SP Mike Mussina SP Scott Kazmir LR Scott Proctor LR Mike Myers MR Kyle Farnsworth MR Chris Ray SU B.J. Ryan SU Mariano Rivera CL Jon Papelbon
Okay, who wins????
I don't know anything about you, but I'm assuming you must be a BoSox fan. Anyone in their right mind would know that Rivera would be the closer, and Beckett (who kinda sucks) would not be the #3 SP.
And the East would win, that lineup would be too ridiculous. I think you can add Hideki Matsui to that lineup (who is almost healthy), when you have Kazmir in there, who is on the DL.
Actually I'm not a Red Sox fan or a Yankee fan. Sorry you're Yankee love blinds you from reality. I'm just going strickly by this year's numbers. Matsui and Shef have barely played this year and would not be on any All-Star team. Liriano is in the same boat that Kazmir is but both have great numbers this year. I'll repeat, Pap has had a better year as closer than Rivera has. Rivera is obviously the better player so far but an All-Star team goes by yearly stats and Pap beats all other closers.
So if you are going by this year's numbers, why in the world would you include Josh Beckett??
He's been terrible this year.
Well who is a better starter than Beckett in the East that hasn't already been included? Johnson? Wang? Lilly? Bedard? Slim pickings if you ask me.
Josh Beckett has a 5.21 ERA and leads the AL in homers given up....
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by Havok1517 » Sun Aug 27, 2006 7:02 pm 
