AL East all stars vs. AL Central all stars...who would win?

[BxBombers951]

i was lookin at the stacked al east and al central and started thinkin to myself...who would win if they made all star teams from each division and had a 5 game series?

i think the east would win... theyd have the better offense to go with a nice rotation of halladay, schilling, moose, kazmir, and possibly randy johnson, and papelbon setting up for mo

any thoughts?

[mrmelo15]

My first thought was Liriano and Santana at the front of the rotation...but if I'm not mistaken the Yanks have had major success against Santana. Somebody correct me if I'm wrong

I think it'd be close, but gotta go with the East.

[Brandaddy]

i think the central would end up winning.
Johan vs. Halladay with the central winning 6-5

[BxBombers951]

i think the central would end up winning.
Johan vs. Halladay with the central winning 6-5

its a 5 game series

[Havok1517]

C Joe Mauer & Victor Martinez
1B Justin Morneau & Paul Konerko
2B Tadahito Iguchi & Luis Castillo
3B Mark Teahen & Joe Crede
SS Carlos Guillen & Jhonny Peralta
LF Scott Podsednik & Marcus Thames
CF Tori Hunter & Grady Sizemore
RF Jermaine Dye & Magglio Ordonez
DH Travis Hafner & Jim Thome

SP Johan Santana
SP Mark Buehrle
SP C.C. Sabathia
SP Justin Verlander
SP Francisco Liriano
LR Dennys Reyes
LR Matt Thornton
MR Fernando Rodney
MR Juan Rincon
SU Joel Zumaya
SU Bobby Jenks
CL Joe Nathan

VS.

C Jorge Posada & Ramon Hernandez
1B Kevin Youkilis & Lyle Overbay
2B Mark Loretta & Brian Roberts
3B Alex Rodriguez & Troy Glaus
SS Derek Jeter & Miguel Tejada
LF Manny Ramirez & Carl Crawford
CF Vernon Wells & Johnny Damon
RF Alex Rios & Bobby Abreu
DH David Oritz & Jason Giambi

SP Roy Halladay
SP Curt Schilling
SP Josh Beckett
SP Mike Mussina
SP Scott Kazmir
LR Scott Proctor
LR Mike Myers
MR Kyle Farnsworth
MR Chris Ray
SU B.J. Ryan
SU Mariano Rivera
CL Jon Papelbon


Okay, who wins????

[BxBombers951]

youk and overbay? what about giambi?

[mrmelo15]

Nevermind. This would be a hell of a series.

I like the Centrals rotation more than the East

[BxBombers951]

also, cano should be there instead of either roberts or loretta

[mrmelo15]

...and I'll go with Yanks here. I think Rivera should be their closer, not that it matters much.

[Havok1517]

also, cano should be there instead of either roberts or loretta

No way, Cano has only played 89 games this season.