this is one of those where I don't knwo what to tell you.
the thing with fantasy is the "swing"
Usually, you trade smoltz, then you don't get his stats, and they are used against you.
But this trade is fairly on target too.
I think I might be of the opinion that if the person has say 250 innings (or so, not doing the math) the commish has a point, smoltz won't make enough of a difference. But at the same time, its not the commih's job to be paying attention to games played and IP. I think at this point, his job should be to see if the trade meets some general defi9nition of "approximate" value, and leave it at that. Or, if "approximate value" can't be met, then looking to see if specific points could be made up overall by such a trade.
Since your trade meets criteria one, It should go through.