In that case, both of them will almost certainly pass you in wins if they have innings left, taking you down 2 points, and possibly in strikeouts too. You have to hope that their pitchers get lit up, increasing their ERA and WHIP to let you recover the points.
I would offer the guy that has Nomar his choice of any combination of your pitchers for Nomar. If there's any chance that adding Nomar or another player can help you move up in other categories, you have to give them whatever they want for pitchers, since your pitchers are now useless to you. Try to offer something like Cabrera and Brown for Nomar, that's a huge upgrade. Also, look and see if you can trade Edmonds or A.Jones combined with a pitcher for a better hitter like Manny, Maggs, etc. Both Edmonds and Jones have been awful lately, but have good overall stats which should give them good trade value still.