Who's got the best lineup in baseball?

[Belle4Hall88]

YANKEES:
Damon, CF
Jeter, SS
Giambi, DH
Rodriguez, 3B
Abreu, RF
Posada, C
Wilson, 1B
Cano, 2B
Williams, LF
*Sheffield & Matsui on DL.

RED SOX:
Youkilius, 1B
Loretta, 2B
Ortiz, DH
Ramirez, RF
Lopez, C
Lowell, 3B
Pena, LF
Crisp, CF
Gonzalez, SS
*Nixon & Varitek on DL.

WHITE SOX:
Podsednick, CF
Iguchi, 2B
Thome, DH
Konerko, 1B
Dye, LF
Crede, 3B
Pierzenski, C
Uribe, SS
Mackowiack, RF

INDIANS:
Sizemore, CF
Inglett, 2B
Hafner, DH
Martinez, C
Blake, 1B
Choo, RF
Peralta, SS
Marte, 3B
Michaels, LF

METS:
Reyes, SS
Lo Duca, C
Beltran, CF
Wright, 3B
Delgado, 1B
Floyd, RF
Valentin, 2B
Millege, LF

BLUE JAYS:
Reed, LF
Rios, RF
Wells, CF
Glaus, 3B
Overbay, 1B
Cat/Hinskie, DH
Molina, C
Adams, 2B
Hill, SS

TIGERS:
Granderson, CF
Guillen, SS
Rodriguez, C
Ordonez, RF
Casey, 1B
Thames, LF
Young/Monroe, DH
Polanco, 2B
Inge, 3B

RANGERS:
Kinsler, 2B
Young, SS
Teixeria, 1B
Lee, LF
Blalock, 3B
Mathews Jr., CF
Stairs/Wilkerson, DH
Laird, C
DeRosa, RF

PHILLIES:
Rollins, SS
Delluci, RF
Utley, 2B
Howard, 1B
Burrell, LF
Rowand, CF
Coste, C
Nunez, 3B

REDS:
Freel, LF
Phillips, 2B
Griffey, CF
Dunn, RF
Encarnation, 3B
Aurilla, SS
Hattenberg, 1B
Ross, C

[giants!]

When healthy, its not evene close, clearly the yankees.

[whoseyourdaddy12]

you sure are enjoying your day off

I think my top 5 in no order would be white sox, yankees, red sox, mets, and rangers.

[Laean]

i voted yankees. mets are close, but that is with the yankees missing matsui and sheff.

[Dr. Duran Duran]

If the Yankees were all healthy, they'd easily win this poll. I said the White Sox for the time being. Pretty solid group from top to bottom.

[BronXBombers51]

If everyone were healthy, the Yankees would win this hands down. With the injuries included, it still might be the Yankees, but it's much closer.

[chadlincoln]

When healthy, easily the Yanks. Abreu, A-rod, Jeter, Sheff, Matsui, Giambi, Damon... wow.

[speedy27]

are you kidding me...the yanks could compare to an all-star NL lineup! Now pitching is another story all together...

[A's]

Yankees all the way, But if you think about the Rangers lineup, it has drastically improved with Teixeira power back. I would say Rangers in second.

[sox 06]

Red Sox
Coco- Speed, some power
Youk- On base machine and some power
Papi- Best clutch hitter ever
Manny- Manny being Manny
Lowell- Comback player of the year
Wily Mo- Power
Gonzalez- Starting to come around
Loretta- Second in comback player of the year voting
Lopez- Solid catcher with average catching stats