Who Should I Get? Adenhart,Adam Miller,H Sanchez, Elbert, or

[dis2233]

Hello- I'm looking to pick up 1 player in my next draft. Long term keeper league Here's a list of the best guys available and how I rank them. Looking for other opinions. I'm looking for SP more than hitting, but if swayed I could change. I already have solid prospects in OF (Butler, Quentin, C. Young, Joel Guzman). Please rank top 10. Thanks in advance.

1)Jeff Francis (still available...figure even though he's in Colorado, he's young and doing well)
2)N. Adenhart
3)Tabata
4)Carlos Gonzalez
5)Hirsh
6)Adam Miller
7)Humberto Sanchez
8)Scott Elbert
9)Gallardo
10)Gio gonzalez
11)Jon Garland (Still available)
12)Vincente Padilla (Still available)
13)Niemann
14)Dukes
15)Bruce

[Galt]

what's your timeframe?

People will likely rank Tabata very high, but are you willing to watch him sit on your minor league roster for the next 3 years?

I'd have Dukes much higher than you have him. He's a 5 category guy, and could very well be starting next year.

[dis2233]

If it's a true ace/top 5 cy race guy then I'll wait...or if it's a 300/30/100/100/25sb I'll wait...if not. I'd like to have guys that will start to contribute either this year or next.

[birdmandig]

Any of these three



9)Gallardo

14)Dukes

15)Bruce

[teddyballgamemvp]

I'd go with Bruce.

[raiders_umpire]

I would take Carlos Gonzalez of the bunch. There is some very options there in Gonzalez, Bruce, Tabata, Adenhart, and Sanchez, but I like Gonzalez the best of the bunch. He has a chance to become a superstar and actually could be the best of the Diamondbacks outfielders.

[PlayingWithFire]

what's with everybody's dislike of Jeff Francis? The guy has ace stuff and he's in the majors already. It's a no brainer here if he's available.

If he's gone then go with Gonzalez, Bruce, Sanchez, Adenhart and Tabata, in that order

[dis2233]

thanks for all of the responses