"Chicks dig the long ball" and apperantly that's all fantasy players notice. This is a guy who had TONS and TONS of doubles and triples. He reminds me more of Chipper Jones than Fred McGriff. A consistant force in the lineup, getting on base and driving in tons of runs.... He's a quinticential #3 hitter. I say Bagwell get in. He was one of the dominant players of the mid-90s.
Oh, and his career most comperables
? Five HoFers (including Micky Mantle), Sheffield, Frank Thomas, Ken Griffey, Andres Galarraga, and err.... Fred McGriff.
So yeah, he gets in. A solid HoFer if not one of the best. Like other have said, probably gets in in a weak year, etc.