dundeeslugger wrote:OK that made no sense what so ever. You told me that Butler is the best pick but then you basically give me all these reasons why he will probably not be called up soon.
Your original question was "which one of these will contribute well next year and be a stud by year 2 or 3?".
I'm saying that I feel Butler shouldn't be called up until 2008. The organization will probably call him up some time later in 2007 which will allow him to contribute well next year. He will be a stud pretty much from day 1 so that fits there as well. Also, he's such a great hitter that given your criteria I'd still take him above the rest of the list even if you got nothing out of him until year 2 and 3...his production in 2008 and 2009 project to be the best of the list that you posted by a pretty good margin.