Geek wrote:In my opinion, there's only one pitcher worth a keeper spot in a keep-three league: Johann Santana.
Not quite. It depends partially on who else you have to choose from. Based on the guy's footer, above, he has to at least consider keeping Peavy.
League size also gets factored in.
As well, the your draft position and the #4 players you forecast the other teams to jettison are also important. If a higher-rated SP is going to fall into your lap in Round 1, you downgrade keeping Peavy and upgrade someone else.
Bottom line is that it is almost always situational.