sportsguy138 wrote:WittyC wrote:A very rough look at a top-10 if I were drafting for '07 tomorrow...
9) King Felix
Liriano wouldn't be far off, but seven starts does not warrant a top-10 position for me. He'd be marginal on my top-20.
the first list has many problems.. but two big ones were peavy and oswalt to far down.. and missing a couple solid pitchers..with this one.. peavy > zam.. halladay > schmidt DEFINETLY... carpenter > schmidt.. carpenter > zam.. halladay > zam.. you put zambrano and schmidt too high up.. carpenter too far down.. king felix infront of carpenter? comon..
I have Peavy and Zamby very close, but Zamby gets the nod b/c of moderate injury concerns with Peavy. Halladay below Schmidt simply because of the K's, but with Schmidt's injury concerns, I understand your point. Carp is down b/c he's only had one dominant season. F-Her (why don't we use this nickname more?) is still the best "prospect" pitcher in the bigs. Don't sleep on him in '07.
I'll concede Schmidt might be a little high, but otherwise I stand by my top 10 at this point in time.