Reyes is a highly rated prospect. He had a great K rate in the minors (over 10 K/9) and excellent control. Add that to the Card's offense (especially with Pujols back) and solid relief support, I think Reyes makes a nice pick-up.
Indeed, I just picked him up myself and dropped Ollie Perez (who I just picked up after his good performance against the Twins).
I am the Master. Don't question the Master. Just do what he says and be proud.