TeamMikeDeveraux wrote:who would you rather have in a non-keeper:
Im trying to pick up one...all are FA's
Depends on what you need. First of all I don't like Cain all that much. His hr/k/bb/ip numbers are not that good this year and were not very good last year either.
Billingsley's control was a bit spotty in the minors and Olsen hasn't been a ton better but if you want strikeouts these are the two I'd look at. Olsen's been up longer so I'd probably go with him but again - only if you need k's.
If you want an all-around pitcher go Reyes. He's more polished at this point, has better command and once Pujols is back plays for a team that should make getting wins fairly easy. He'll probably give you a lower k/9 than Billingsley or Olsen but I think overall he's the better pitcher.