Vote Off: Greatest of the Great

[Tavish]

Same rules.

Vote one up, one down.

5 people must vote after before you can vote again.


Which player was the greatest at their particular sport?

Take the question however you want. Your favorite, the most dominant, which one you would want in their prime to start your team with, etc.

I'm sure there will be plenty of people who want write in votes, but too bad. Its my list and (other than hockey where I didn't think anyone would argue against Gretsky) I tried to get a decent cross-section of positions and eras. Hell I even took the greatest baseball player ever off the list so no one should complain about the other choices.

Babe Ruth 5
Barry Bonds 5
Willie Mays 5
Walter Johnson 5
Wayne Gretsky 5
Michael Jordan 5
Wilt Chamberlain 5
Bill Russell 5
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar 5
Jerry Rice 5
Dan Marino 5
Jim Brown 5
Lawerence Taylor 5
Reggie White 5
Tiger Woods 5

[PlayingWithFire]

wow, Tav. At least put Lemieux in there.

[PlayingWithFire]

Babe Ruth 5
Barry Bonds 5
Willie Mays 5
Walter Johnson 5
Wayne Gretsky 5
Michael Jordan 6
Wilt Chamberlain 5
Bill Russell 5
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar 5
Jerry Rice 5
Dan Marino 5
Jim Brown 5
Lawerence Taylor 4
Reggie White 5
Tiger Woods 5
Mario Lemieux 5

[Tavish]

wow, Tav. At least put Lemieux in there.

That would give the list too many Canadians.

[PlayingWithFire]

wow, Tav. At least put Lemieux in there.

That would give the list too many Canadians.

what's your problem with Canadians? You are talking to one.

and as Supernick of this board will tell you: Mario is a Quebecois

[EnFuego]

Babe Ruth 5
Barry Bonds 5
Willie Mays 5
Walter Johnson 5
Wayne Gretsky 5
Michael Jordan 7
Wilt Chamberlain 5
Bill Russell 5
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar 5
Jerry Rice 5
Dan Marino 5
Jim Brown 5
Lawerence Taylor 3
Reggie White 5
Tiger Woods 5
Mario Lemieux 5

[brewcrew4you]

Babe Ruth 5
Barry Bonds 5
Willie Mays 5
Walter Johnson 4
Wayne Gretsky 6
Michael Jordan 7
Wilt Chamberlain 5
Bill Russell 5
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar 5
Jerry Rice 5
Dan Marino 5
Jim Brown 5
Lawerence Taylor 3
Reggie White 5
Tiger Woods 5
Mario Lemieux 5

[blankman]

Babe Ruth 5
Barry Bonds 5
Willie Mays 5
Walter Johnson 4
Wayne Gretsky 6
Michael Jordan 7
Wilt Chamberlain 5
Bill Russell 5
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar 5
Jerry Rice 5
Dan Marino 5
Jim Brown 5
Lawerence Taylor 4
Reggie White 4
Tiger Woods 5
Mario Lemieux 5

[Tavish]

Babe Ruth 5
Barry Bonds 5
Willie Mays 5
Walter Johnson 4
Wayne Gretsky 6
Michael Jordan 7
Wilt Chamberlain 6
Bill Russell 4
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar 5
Jerry Rice 5
Dan Marino 5
Jim Brown 5
Lawerence Taylor 4
Reggie White 4
Tiger Woods 5

[MMoNeY24]

Babe Ruth 5
Barry Bonds 5
Willie Mays 5
Walter Johnson 4
Wayne Gretzky 6
Michael Jordan 7
Wilt Chamberlain 6
Bill Russell 3
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar 5
Jerry Rice 5
Dan Marino 5
Jim Brown 5
Lawerence Taylor 5
Reggie White 4
Tiger Woods 5