Haren, Acevedo or Shields?

[Hyde]

Who would you pick out of these 3 for just the rest of this season. Haren is on a good hitting team, but I've never seen him pitch. Jose Acevedo has great stats in his 3 starts, but haven't seen him pitch either. Scot Shields I have seen pitch and he has great stuff. They are letting him start now that they cut Appier. So who would you take?

[pkarr5000]

1. haren
2. shields
3. acevedo

[DieHardCubbie]

1. haren
2. shields
3. acevedo

[crazybob60]

1. Haren
2. Acevedo




3. Shields (not sold on him yet)

[Dog]

Haren has been outstanding other than one start.

[thehat]

Haren, followed by Acevedo. Shields is a good pitcher, but is unlikely to go past 5-6 innings, which really hurts his chances of scoring W's.

[Madison]

Haren
Acevedo/Shields---Shields did well starting earlier this year, but got beat up his last time out. If he does well in his next start, I rank him over Acevedo.