quitesanemax wrote:Thats someone who was seriously undervaluing Peavy. I tried to trade Halliday and Gordon for Peavy and Papelbon just the other day (just before his last start), and he refused the trade... he overvalued Papelbon, IMO. He might end up regretting that one.
I would have rejected that offer as well.
I don't think it was a bad offer. I think Halladay, even when I sent that trade, is a little more valuable than Peavy. It seems that people undervalue Gordon a bit, and maybe (this from a Red Sox fan) over value Papelbon a bit. I don't know if it was the greatest trade offer, but it was fair. As I said, he might end up regretting not accepting it. We'll see, I guess. I have Sheets, Burnett, and Patterson on the DL, so, if Peavy ends up on the DL, I'm certainly glad he didn't accept it.