Rate Team A or Team B (WHIR)

[NikkiSixx]

In a standard 5X5 Roto, 14 team league, which team would you rather have over the course of a season? Just a simple "Team A" or "Team B" will do, thanks.


Team A

C - Lo Duca
1B - Helton
2B - Roberts
3B - Ensberg
SS - Jeter
OF - Abreu
OF - Sheffield
OF - Kearns
Util - Wilkerson

Bench - Cliff Floyd, Jose Guillen(DL), Frank Thomas, Placido Polanco

SP - J. Santana
SP - P. Martinez
RP - T. Gordon
RP - A. Benitez
P - R. Soriano
P - J. Patterson (DL)
P - Matt Cain

Bench - Oliver Perez, Bob Howry, Jake Westbrook, Octavio Dotel


Team B

C - Willingham
1B - Pujols
2B - Cano
3B - Chavez
SS - Peralta
OF - Berkman
OF - Holliday
OF - Pierre
Util - Giambi

Bench - J.D. Drew, Michael Cuddyer, Ian Kinsler, Rocco Baldelli(DL)

SP - J. Peavy
SP - J. Schmidt
RP - D. Turnbow
RP - A. Otsuka
P - J.J. Putz
P - S. Kazmir
P - J. Contreras

Bench - Todd Coffey, Scott Linebrink, Chris Young



It would be nice if you could put down a couple of reasons why you chose the team you chose.

Thanks, give me your link so I can help you out.

[Gold Rush]

I'd give the edge to team A in speed, and the edge to team B in saves, but other than that, it's pretty much a wash. I would take team B's pitching staff overall, but you can't deny the production team A will get out of its 1-2 punch.

[guilly_99]

I give it to A simply because the offense is much more balanced, practically no SBs with B with the exception of Pierre. The pitching staff is too strong with A b/c of the anchors in Santana and Pedro. To get both is amazing.

[nissan_350z]

This is a hard one. I think team A is slightly better due to a better offense w/ speed. But I really don't think the teams are that different. Team B has a lot more depth with its starting pitching, and will get many more saves. Other than Santana and Pedro, Team A doesn't have good starting pitching. Gordon is the only decent Relief pitcher on team A while team B has 3 servicable relief pitchers. The better hitting of team A and the better pitching of team B kinda offset eachother, and render the teams equal. That being said, I'll always take hitting over pitching.

Mine: http://fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/v ... p?t=210275

[sportsfan1433]

I have to give it to team A too. That pitching is awesome. I would try to improve a little on Helton. He is having a terrible year this year.

[NikkiSixx]

bump.

[DWright5]

i would say team A becuase you have the 2 best pitchers in fantasy baseball IMO along with first round hitting in abreu plus helton jeter and ensberg are all great hitters, thanks for the help on mine

[Blandest]

Thanks for help on mine.

Team B by a slight edge. The pitching staff in Team A lacks depth besides Santana and Pedro. Both team's hitting is absolutely stacked in a 14-teamer, and I could see you winning in both leagues.

[Frappy]

Team A

[Team D-Mizz]

stupid question probably, but what does whir mean.