you have a really good team and i'd be happy to have a poll to settle it, but my argument is based on the fact that, while you have 2 good closers in lidge and nathan, dempster is your only other reliever and you never know when he's going to pull a danny graves on everyone. I have 5 relievers, all with playoff contenders. johan, peavy, and schmidt havent even had their best stuff yet, and my era, whip, and k's are still top notch.f
try to pick someone on my team you would drop. difficult isnt it? haren? hudson? giambi?