I don't think he really did that badly last year. His second half splits were quite good, actually. I know you have to factor in every start, but if you take away his worst four starts last year, he would have had a 3.45 ERA. Considering he was battling an injury for a good part of the season, I really don't think it's all that bad. I have him as my #3 starter behind Peavy and Pettite and couldn't be happier. Sure, he'll have a few bad starts here and there, but overall, the good ones should far outweigh the bad ones.