You need a real catcher. And I say that with all possible love for my Mike Piazza. He should be DHing, he wears down fast, misses a lot of time, and is in a terrible park. I would check out other catchers on the WW and see if ANYONE has ANYTHING useful you can trade Piazza for. There might be some nice sleepers at C on waivers. Try McCaan or Doumit or Barajas.