Free agent second basemen evals

[timkell]

The three guys have been playing very well for the past month:
Mark Loretta
Alex Cintron
Brian Roberts

They're all available in my league. Thoughts on whether any of these guys could be better than Marcus Giles or Luis Castillo in a points league? I doubt it, but I don't know much about them either.

[Super GM]

Are you thinking about replacing Giles or Castillo with one of these guys? Whatever you do, don't do it. Marcus Giles is an All-Star and Castillo is, well, he's just Castillo. If you can add Cintron for somebody else, then do so....

[easygoing]

Giles is a bum who played over his head for a month. Go after Roberts!!

[Ousmagic]

out of these 3 players id most like to have loretta but no way id have him over castillo or giles

[d]

Don't replace Giles or Castillo with any of these three guys. Both Cintron and Roberts are good as an infield backup though.

[Guest]

Marcus Giles does not merit his all-star status over Vidro. I'd rather have Castillo then Giles any day. Giles is overrated, Castillo is underrated.

[timkell]

In 5X5 leagues, I'd give Castillo the nod, but in a points league, I think Giles takes it. Home runs and doubles become way more important than average in a points league and considering Castillo isn't running so much, I'd say Giles is better for points leagues, as long as he breaks out of his slump, that is!

[CaptainJenks]

I would have to pass on that