I'd probably take C. Young. I've never been a big fan of Guillen, he is a nice player but doesn't offer anything really good. Now he is on an awful offensive team/park, has a wrist injury he wants to play with, and will be 30. I just don't think his value will be going up anytime soon and would unload him before something like wrist surgery (though he doesn't want it now) plummets his value. Young might never give you avg., but he should contribute in every other category.