BETTER TEAM? MORE IMPORTANT... BETTER OF???

[alxb14]

These are the two teams in question, it would be nice to know which one you think is better overall, but also say who has the best outfield.

TEAM ONE

C- Ivan Rodriguez
1B- Lance Berkman
2B- Placido Polanco
SS- Jose Reyes
3B- Eric Chavez
OF- Vlad Guerrero (keeper)
OF- Jason Bay
OF- Scott Podsednik
Util- Adam Dunn

SP- Jason Schmidt
SP- Barry Zito
SP- Roger Clemens
RP- Tom Gordon
RP- Ryan Dempster
P- Joe Blanton
P- Tim Hudson
P- John Lieber

BN- Prince Fielder
BN- Adam Eaton
BN- Ronnie Belliard
BN- Jhonny Peralta
BN- Chris Ray
BN- Louis Gonzalez


Team 2:

C Joe Mauer
1b Lyle Overbay
2b Mark Loretta
SS Nomar Garciaparra
3b Melvin Mora
OF Miguel Cabrera
OF Carl Crawford
OF Jonny Damon
Utl Kevin Mench
BN Brian Roberts


SP Randy Johnson
Sp Brandon Webb
Sp Mike Mussina
RP Brad Lidge
RP Francisco Cordero
P Kevin Millwood
P Mike Gonzolez
P David Weathers
BN Tom Glavine
BN Paul Byrd
BN Carl Pavono
BN chen-ming Wang

12 team H2H 1 keeper 5x5

[yanks24716]

i like team one both questions

[TKBomber7285]

I would have to say I favor team 1 by a little bit overall and has the better outfield easily. In fact the outfield is a major part of the reason I favor team 1 overall, since with the uncertainty of Clemens team 2 has an advantage in the pitching aspect.

[loosechange75]

I personally like team B, they have a great overall team, good speed descent Sp's some nice closers a great OF followed by a solid IF. On th eout field question i am sry but i have to say team b here to because of there speed, runs and avg that 3 out of the 5 hitting stats

[Milto]

Team 1 has a better OF by a smidge. I'd also take team 1 overall.

[alxb14]

Everyone can go ahead and disregard lossechange's comment for somewhat obvious reasons...

[blackmarketbaby]

team one rocks my socks, dempster/clemens questions aside.

[Pogotheostrich]

TEAM ONE is better IMO.

For OF if we are only counting

OF- Vlad Guerrero
OF- Jason Bay
OF- Scott Podsednik

vs.

OF Miguel Cabrera
OF Carl Crawford
OF Jonny Damon

I'll take team 2, but team one does have the option of adding Dunn or Berkman to the OF.