Debate Schedule

[giants!]

There is one stickied but its moving slowly. The Suppasonic vs. Daullaz debate will end mid afternoon tomorrow. A normal debate will probably have about 4 posts from each person.

[cordscords]

I'm gonna have to pull out. I just dont like the idea of being told "defend this side". Sure I could BS my way through it, but it just wouldnt be the same.

[PlayingWithFire]

who judge the winner?

[giants!]

Cordscords, are you sure?

[giants!]

who judge the winner?

4 panel members have one vote, the cafe voters are one vote

[GotowarMissAgnes]

Art Vandelay vs GTWMA April 8-10

I look forward to this one. Both are well spoken and both think out their posts pretty well.

on edit: I didn't read the post right above mine until just now - 2 minutes after posting the above.

I was looking at Art's posts and he and I seem to agree on a lot of things. I just hope I don't have to defend Omar's candidacy for Hall of Fame!

[DK]

Art Vandelay vs GTWMA April 8-10

I look forward to this one. Both are well spoken and both think out their posts pretty well.

on edit: I didn't read the post right above mine until just now - 2 minutes after posting the above.

I was looking at Art's posts and he and I seem to agree on a lot of things. I just hope I don't have to defend Omar's candidacy for Hall of Fame!

Or Calvin Pickering's inability as a baseball player.

[davidmarver]

I'm gonna have to pull out. I just dont like the idea of being told "defend this side". Sure I could BS my way through it, but it just wouldnt be the same.

Same here...sure I could make an argument for something, but we're here to help fantasy players; I don't want to give advice I wouldn't myself follow. Count me out if we are assigned positions.

Sorry, David.

[baseball6791]

I'm gonna have to pull out. I just dont like the idea of being told "defend this side". Sure I could BS my way through it, but it just wouldnt be the same.

Same here...sure I could make an argument for something, but we're here to help fantasy players; I don't want to give advice I wouldn't myself follow. Count me out if we are assigned positions.

Sorry, David.

It is highly unlikely that it will come to that... if you go back and read the post I made, you will not be assinged positions. For questions with multiple answers, we may choose to exclude some answers because they are obvious and we would like some variation (for example: what off-season move hurt a players fantasy value the most? the obvious answer would be alfonso soriano, so for that question, soriano would not be an option), this way, we get people on different sides of an issue as much as possible. For questions where we can't do that, and it is inevitable that people are arguing the same side, we will vote based on quality of the arguement

[giants!]

Yes, we are changing the assigned positions stance. Most questions will have more than one choice