cordscords wrote:What happens if we agree with each other, and support the same amount of good facts backing up our opinions?
Then what do we do? THE MADNESS!
George_Foreman wrote:quick question: what happens if (god forbid) both people are on the same side of the topic?
We haven't made a final decision yet, but giants and I had discussed this and we think that it will probably work something like this:
For questions that are very open ended, such as many of the history questions might be, we will leave it up to the debaters to choose their person/side/thing/etc. to argue for. Hopefully with those questions people don't pick the same thing, but if they do happen to, we will throw that out as a possible answer, and if they keep choosing the same thing, we will continue to throw out those, until they choose different things. For questions that are open ended but have a smaller range of possible choices and/or have one answer that is completely obvious and will inevitabely be chosen by both people, we will provide a list to choose from, or exclude certain possible answers. For questions that have 2 answers, unfortunately, there is no way to make sure that people have different answers without it being unfair to someone. We may also just choose sides for people, and they have to find a way to argue that side.
Our goal is to make this as much a "debate" as possible, with people arguing for different sides, and the way we have set it up we should be able to do that in most cases. If people choose the same side in a 2 answer question, we will vote based on the strength of the arguements given.