If you could rate my team by answering three questions...

[dmbpanic]

12 team 5x5 h2h Yahoo Public league. I had the 12th and final pick:

C: R. Hernandez (R14)
1B: C. Tracy (R10)
2B: R. Weeks (R7)
SS: F. Lopez (R6)
3B: D. Wright (R1)
OF: B. Abreu (R2)
OF: C. Beltran (R3)
OF: M. Holliday (R9)
Util: B. Crosby (R15)
B: C. Shelton (R18)
B: J. Willingham (R19)
B: B. Wilkerson (R20)

SP: R. Johnson (R4)
SP: F. Hernandez (R5)
SP: M. Cain (R11)
SP: S. Kazmir (R12)
SP: F. Liriano (R16)
SP: J. Weaver (R17)
SP: S. Chacon (R21)
RP: E. Gagne (R8)
RP: J. Valverde (R13)

ok...let me have it

Q1: Rank on a scale from 1-10
Q2: Weakness
Q3: Which player(s) did I grab too early and which did I get at a discount?

Thanks in advance for your feedback!

[whoseyourdaddy12]

12 team 5x5 h2h Yahoo Public league. I had the 12th and final pick:

C: R. Hernandez (R14)
1B: C. Tracy (R10)
2B: R. Weeks (R7)
SS: F. Lopez (R6)
3B: D. Wright (R1)
OF: B. Abreu (R2)
OF: C. Beltran (R3)
OF: M. Holliday (R9)
Util: B. Crosby (R15)
B: C. Shelton (R18)
B: J. Willingham (R19)
B: B. Wilkerson (R20)

SP: R. Johnson (R4)
SP: F. Hernandez (R5)
SP: M. Cain (R11)
SP: S. Kazmir (R12)
SP: F. Liriano (R16)
SP: J. Weaver (R17)
SP: S. Chacon (R21)
RP: E. Gagne (R8)
RP: J. Valverde (R13)

ok...let me have it

Q1: Rank on a scale from 1-10
Q2: Weakness
Q3: Which player(s) did I grab too early and which did I get at a discount?

Thanks in advance for your feedback!

A1:6.8/10
A2:Id say pitching, get another closer or two
A3:not sure, i dont do snake drafts

Please help me

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/foru ... p?t=172454

[GoatCurse03]

1. I'd say an 8 of 10. Nice balance.
2. I'd want another closer, too, but you can find one during the season on WW.
3. You have more underpays than over.
Hernandez you got a few rounds later than in most drafts
Holliday is a couple rounds earlier than he's worth imo, but that is where he will go, so no biggie.
Crosby has a recent report of shoulder tendonitis, but that came after you drafted him, still a couple rounds early though
Shelton is a good pick in the 18th, probably 4 rounds later than I'd expect.
Willingham is a few rounds early, but by then who cares, he's going to be good.
Wilkerson in the 20th? Wow, a heist, probably best value pick of your draft.
RJ--when will he go? 4th is late, imo, so nicely done

[The Last Expo]

Yeah, I'd have to say pretty nicely done 7.5-8/10. Have to agree Wilkerson in the 20th round is an unbelievable steal. It will pay-off big when he drills 30 dingers this year in Texas. I'd put him in your util slot over Crosby. Good job.

[Saintyopa]

I agree, about an 8 out of 10. Watch Liriano though. He probably wont start unless he has an unreal spring. Word here is that the job is bakers to lose. They might give Liriano a season in the bullpen, like they did with Johan. Of course, Kyle Lohse sucks, so Liriano could end up starting not long into the season.

I think Shelton in the 18th is a steal. If he learns to hit the lefties, he could put up unreal stats. And yes Wilkerson is a steal. Especially if they have him bat lead off.

[dmbpanic]

Thanks for the feedback...greatly appreciated!