Rank these Prospects

[05worldserieschamps]

I am in a 12 Team, Non Keeper League that is Head to head. Which one of these Prospects is best???

Ian Kinsler
Ryan Zimmerman
Brian Anderson

Which would be the best to have on a Fantasy Team in 2006?

[Zito is God]

In 2006 it goes:

Zimmerman

Kinsler

Anderson

[hybrid]

Kinsler - great line up, great ball park, can play 2B/SS in yahoo

Zimmerman - 2nd because even though I think he plays a deep position, he has a better chance to hit and not be replaced like Anderson.

Anderson - I think if go things go right he could have a pretty nice year, but he is a bit risky.

[Zito is God]

Kinsler - great line up, great ball park, can play 2B/SS in yahoo

Zimmerman - 2nd because even though I think he plays a deep position, he has a better chance to hit and not be replaced like Anderson.

Anderson - I think if go things go right he could have a pretty nice year, but he is a bit risky.

I feel Zimmerman has much more job security then Kinsler does and therefore ranked him higher.

[hybrid]

I feel Zimmerman has much more job security then Kinsler does and therefore ranked him higher.

I agree, but I also think Kinsler has a good chance to start. After that I'd take Kinsler over a loaded 3B position and a prospect that doesn't have much power.

[raiders_umpire]

In a non keeper league, I can only see Kinsler being productive enough this year to be on a fantasy 12 team roster. But I don't think his job is stable enough to be picked in the draft, just somebody to keep a eye on after the draft.

[Zito is God]

In a non keeper league, I can only see Kinsler being productive enough this year to be on a fantasy 12 team roster. But I don't think his job is stable enough to be picked in the draft, just somebody to keep a eye on after the draft.

You're kidding. You see Kinsler outperforming Zimmerman THIS YEAR???

[Sultans of Squat]

You're kidding. You see Kinsler outperforming Zimmerman THIS YEAR???

Why not? It's not *that* much of a stretch in fantasy terms. Sure, it's very debatable, but why be so shocked? It's not like Zimm will have tons of potential for R and RBI or HR playing for the Nats this year. And 3B is a pretty deep position compared to 2B. If Kinsler does stick as a regular, there's good likelihood that he'll end up being more valuable than Zimm in fantasy terms. Of course, that's IF he sticks.