Is Bay first round material?

[tuckerman85]

Who would you guys rather have, Bay or Wright? I'm hoping to get M-Cab with the last pick of my 10 teamer, and then grab one of these two. I'm lost as to which one though. I'm leaning toward Wright as stands though...

I'd take bay, and that is just beause, this year I've actually had more difficulty finding quality OF later in the draft, which hasnt been the case in prior years. There are some good picks at OF later, but a lot of them arent proven. And 3b seems to be pretty deep this year.

[BronXBombers51]

Who would you guys rather have, Bay or Wright? I'm hoping to get M-Cab with the last pick of my 10 teamer, and then grab one of these two. I'm lost as to which one though. I'm leaning toward Wright as stands though...

I'd take bay, and that is just beause, this year I've actually had more difficulty finding quality OF later in the draft, which hasnt been the case in prior years. There are some good picks at OF later, but a lot of them arent proven. And 3b seems to be pretty deep this year.

Well if I took Wright, I'd put M-Cab in the OF. If I took Bay, I'd put him in the OF and M-Cab on 3B.

I'm going to wind up with a 3B and OF no matter what, I just don't know if I want it to be M-Cab and Wright or M-Cab and Bay.

[beltrans_boy]

I'd take MCab any day of the week over Bay. Wright is a great pick.

[MotorCityKitties]

Who would you guys rather have, Bay or Wright? I'm hoping to get M-Cab with the last pick of my 10 teamer, and then grab one of these two. I'm lost as to which one though. I'm leaning toward Wright as stands though...

I'd take bay, and that is just beause, this year I've actually had more difficulty finding quality OF later in the draft, which hasnt been the case in prior years. There are some good picks at OF later, but a lot of them arent proven. And 3b seems to be pretty deep this year.

Well if I took Wright, I'd put M-Cab in the OF. If I took Bay, I'd put him in the OF and M-Cab on 3B.

I'm going to wind up with a 3B and OF no matter what, I just don't know if I want it to be M-Cab and Wright or M-Cab and Bay.

BB51, I made my picks last night. MCab and Bay.

[Yoda]

Who would you guys rather have, Bay or Wright? I'm hoping to get M-Cab with the last pick of my 10 teamer, and then grab one of these two. I'm lost as to which one though. I'm leaning toward Wright as stands though...

I'd take bay, and that is just beause, this year I've actually had more difficulty finding quality OF later in the draft, which hasnt been the case in prior years. There are some good picks at OF later, but a lot of them arent proven. And 3b seems to be pretty deep this year.

Well if I took Wright, I'd put M-Cab in the OF. If I took Bay, I'd put him in the OF and M-Cab on 3B.

I'm going to wind up with a 3B and OF no matter what, I just don't know if I want it to be M-Cab and Wright or M-Cab and Bay.

I would go with Wright. He has a higher ceiling at the moment (due to his age), better supporting cast and gives you better position flexibility (which isn't huge but still).

[TheRock]

I had the 12th pick in my public league. I took Bay and Wright. Good choice?

I read up on Bay and it seems he is a definite number 1 pick, especially since he provides ALL 5 categories, also his constant improvement over the last 3 years. Any good discussion for or against this view?

For that matter, did I do the right thing with Wright?

Good picks methinks.

Who did you pass on?

[BigLebowski]

I agree on Abreu. He TORTURED me in the 2nd half last season. That home run derby screwed up his swing. Pray your players don't win the home run derby.

If last year is any indication, I think that Bay is safe from winning the HR Derby.

[RynMan]

I love Wright and Bay, and landed them with the 9th and 12th pick in a keeper league. I think for this season, both guys are end of the first round, early 2nd type players.

[Zito is God]

I had the 12th pick in my public league. I took Bay and Wright. Good choice?

I read up on Bay and it seems he is a definite number 1 pick, especially since he provides ALL 5 categories, also his constant improvement over the last 3 years. Any good discussion for or against this view?

For that matter, did I do the right thing with Wright?

Good picks methinks.

Who did you pass on?

I passed on Abreu, he was the one I had a hard time letting go.

I can't see MCab's value over Bay's. Bay steals bags and MCab's supporting cast is pathetic right now (Bay's ain't great, but at least he has someone to drive him in!).

[Jackalope]

Who would you guys rather have, Bay or Wright? I'm hoping to get M-Cab with the last pick of my 10 teamer, and then grab one of these two. I'm lost as to which one though. I'm leaning toward Wright as stands though...

I'd rather wright.