Is Bay first round material?

[rjforlife]

i dont like abreu at all at that pick. his power seems to be on a decline and you never know when he will stop stealing....think you made the right picks

[BronXBombers51]

Who would you guys rather have, Bay or Wright? I'm hoping to get M-Cab with the last pick of my 10 teamer, and then grab one of these two. I'm lost as to which one though. I'm leaning toward Wright as stands though...

[Jmar]

I agree on Abreu. He TORTURED me in the 2nd half last season. That home run derby screwed up his swing. Pray your players don't win the home run derby.

[kemper5]

I like your 2 first picks..

[George_Foreman]

If MCab gets 3B eligible this year, I'd probably go with Bay. Otherwise, it's Wright. I see them putting up similar lines with Bay's AVG and HR slightly better and Wright posting better periferrals.

[pat1999]

bay and wright are two great pieces to start a winning team with for sure...your getting 40sb 60hr 200r 200rbi for sure from them and they should both hit .300


i have wright in my top 10 with bay knockin on the door at 12

[Ender]

For what its worth in my draft I ended up with Cabrera and Wright. I just couldn't see taking Bay over Mcab since he fell to me with the 13th pick and I like Wright at 3B more than Bay in the OF.

[nuggets]

1 year:

MCab/Bay/Wright (they all have the +/-)


Abreu

Keeper:

MCab
Wright

Bay


Abreu

[converge241]

i think jason bay is a 1st round pick in a 12 or 14 team (or larger obviously)

i love the guy and think he will be great this year but even i would have a little trepidation

taking him say 10, 9,8 etc

i have seen him go that high but id be a little nervous compared to the other guys out there to pick from in that spot

[TurdFerguson]

IMO Figgins is the most overrated player in fantasy baseball beause of the position elegibilityand his speed.No way I would ever even consider taking him before round 5 there are so many players that are better than him.