Jeter or Rollins?

[Yoda]

Jeter is the safer pick... but Rollins has higher upside at this point.

If you were to go with Rollins, you probably want to try and get a decent backup just in case.

[Simulacrum]

If you are in need of more steals go with Rollins if you want more hr and rbi go with Jeter.

For that reason I would pick Rollins. Not a ton of base-thieving SS's out there.

[DevilDriver]

Rollins is overrated because of the great season he had..I'd taken Jeter pretty easily

[Amazinz]

Other than SB Rollins had a slightly better year in 2004 than 2005 basically across the board. Of course those 11 extra SB increased his value quite a bit.

[Pokey]

I have Rollins rated higher this year.

[DevilDriver]

Other than SB Rollins had a slightly better year in 2004 than 2005 basically across the board. Of course those 11 extra SB increased his value quite a bit.

I meant that 26 game hit streak and all the hype surrounding that...

[tuckerman85]

being a sox fan, i have a no yankee policy!

not really, but i dont like picking them and then watching the sox yanks games and kinda hoping for certain scenerios where i'd get points but the sox would still win. Rollins for me though cuz the speed.