Wow Tex is not even in my top 5 picks for a keeper league. The away stats scare me especially with his free agency coming up in a few years. The top 4 are pretty easy imo. The top 2 are interchangeable depending on your personal preference, and 3rd and 4th are interchangeable depending on if you prefer the young player or the prime age veteran.
My top 5 keeper picks
Wright/ Santana -- If h2h, I will take Wright, but if roto, I will take Santana. After these 2, then I will be looking at Tex, Crawford, Manny, and Bay.