Minor League Help

[giants!]

30ab/20ip limit
have to choose 3, with the following people already taken.

Joe Blanton P Oak, Ryan Langerhans OF Atl, Francisco Liriano P Min, Cesar Carillo SP SD
Jose Capellan P Mil, Huston Street P Oak, Cole Hamels P Phi, Carlos Quentin OF Ari
Ian Kinster SS Tex, Kenji Johjima C Sea, Josh Barfield 2B SD, Scott Olsen SP Fla

Felix Hernandez P Sea, Ian Stewart 3B Col, Joel Guzman SS LAD, Eric Duncan 3B NYY

Casey Kotchman 1B LAA, Matt Cain RHP Giants, Brandon Wood SS LAA, Alex Gordon 3B KC

Nick Markakis OF Bal , Hanley Ramirez SS Fla, Craig Hansen RP Bos, Jon Lester SP Bos Dan Johnson 1B Oak, Chris Burke 2B Hou,

Justin Verlander SP Det, Andy LaRoche 3B LAD
Andy Phillips 1B NYY, Justin Upton SS Ari, Stephen Drew SS Ari,
Chad Billinsly P LAD

Lastings Milledge OF NYM Prince Fielder 1B MIL, Anthony Reyes SP StL, Ricky Weeks 2B Mil

Merkin Valdez RP SF, Willy Taveras OF Hou, Erick Aybar SS LAA, Melky Cabrera OF NYY

Delmon Young OF TB,
Thanks

[SouthBronxBombers]

Billy Butler
Joe Papelbon
Ryan Zimmerman

I don't see how Chris Burke can be on that list.

[giants!]

It includes picks from last year who were kept

Zimmerman and Paplebon are over the ip/ab limit

[Jenkins]

You pretty much have to take Billy Butler and Bobby Jenks.

Others should be
Jon Papelbon
Yusmeiro Petit

[giants!]

Papelbon and Jenks are over the limit.

Felix Pie and Daric Barton are avaialable. What are the thoughts on them

[rhd]

My three would be:

- H. Kendrick
- D. Barton
- C. Young

Pie wouldnt be a bad choice either.

[hybrid]

I'd have to say Butler, Kendrick, and Pelfrey. That gives you a future power hitter @ 1B/DH, a very good 2B prospect, and a top pitching prospect.

[thedude]

I'd have to say Butler, Kendrick, and Pelfrey. That gives you a future power hitter @ 1B/DH, a very good 2B prospect, and a top pitching prospect.

My problem with Pelfrey is, TINSTAAPP.


I'd go Butler, Kendrick, and Saltalamacchia.

One good DH power hitter, a potenial batting champ. Salty is the real deal, and cathcer who can hit are hard to find.

[hybrid]

My problem with Pelfrey is, TINSTAAPP.


I'd go Butler, Kendrick, and Saltalamacchia.

One good DH power hitter, a potenial batting champ. Salty is the real deal, and cathcer who can hit are hard to find.

I think it gets to the point where it's just over-stated. If you have a top pitching prospect and they have no glaring reasons for them getting hurt, you go ahead and take them. Salty is just as likely to move to another position as Pelfrey is to have a major injury, and that would dim his value quite a bit.

[giants!]

Which of the 3 pitchers are the best

Pelfrey
Petit
Zumaya