Damon, Crisp, Holliday, Wells, or Giles?

[Andy1234]

Who's the best of this group of OF (5x5 roto) How would you rank them?

Do any stand out as they do not belong with the others? (either better or worse than the rest)

[Aces Wild]

Damon
Wells

Giles
Holliday
Crisp

[BravesGuy]

Damon easily...will be hitting in the 1 spot for the yanks.

[J.C.Fighter]

Damon
Wells
Holliday
Crisp/ Giles

[Rohan]

Damon
Wells
Holliday 30+ homers?
Crisp 20+ homers and a lot of runs scored 100+
Giles 20 homers 10 sb

I'd rank Giles higher if you play in a league that counts BB, or OBP

[NZF]

Damon easily...will be hitting in the 1 spot for the yanks.

I wouldn't say Damon easily but he should be No. 1
then

Crisp
Wells
Giles
Holliday

Those that have Damon and Crisp well apart are way off base.

[daullaz]

Damon

Holliday
Wells
Crisp

Giles

[Grouperman941]

Damon
Crisp
Wells
Holliday
Giles

[RynMan]

Damon is far from easily the best player in this group. Don't expect another .316 avg as that was his career high. I think with the short porch in right at Yankee stadium he may hit 15 dingers. The number of steals he has had have been in decline for the past several years. I think Coco Crisp is right there in terms of value. Damon is going to be drafted higher than he should based on his name - which is why he won't be on any of my teams.

[TB13]

Damon, first is a no-brainer. Follwed by

Wells
Crisp
Holiday
Giles

Holiday and Giles are a toss-up, IMO.