Lets argue............. Soriano
Utley,my homer pic
Kent,still gettin it done
Giles,WILL BOUNCE BACK
Cantu,awesome numbers
the rest
Loretta,i smell comeback
Iguchi,Has more to show
Weeks,a fluke?let someone else see
Ellis,Oaklands new bright star
Biggio,luvin that minutemaid
Roberts and Vidro were left out due to injury concerns.
There ya have it,your thoughts?
I think Id also move Soriano down to third even though his overall stats looked good his splits are ugly. Playing half of his games at a pitcher friendly park will really hurt. Ill definetely be avoiding him next year.
I don't know where to put Weeks, but last year was far from a fluke, his numbers will improve this year. An injury held him back for half of last year or his numbers would have been stronger.
Ellis is not a bright new star either, he's 28 years old and his average was almost completely driven by a high H% which he is unlikely to sustain.
Silverz list below is a good one, I'd make minor adjustments but nothing is glaringly out of place on it. I would probably stick Weeks at the bottom of tier 3, not so much because I think he will be better than cano this year, but more because he actually has the potential to join Utley in tier 1 if he somehow explodes this year and none of the others below tier 3 have much tier jumping upside.
Last edited by Ender on Mon Jan 23, 2006 4:58 pm, edited 3 times in total.