Best player in team history

[Tavish]

I was writing it at 1 in the morning, Cobb and Greenberg are clearly better

I was just giving you a little hell. Our lists aren't too far apart. About the biggest differences was I went with a few more older players and I think Gibson is way over-rated.

[wags6817]

Hey Giants, I think Hans Wagner and Roberto were both better than Captain Willie. Hans Wagner was one of the first great players.

[teddy ballgame]

What about Cy Young with Boston? He wasn't there his whole career, but he has the most wins in Red Sox history. Although I can't argue against Ted, as you can see.

<---

[giants!]

Hey Giants, I think Hans Wagner and Roberto were both better than Captain Willie. Hans Wagner was one of the first great players.

They were both probably better but I went with younger players more often than not. As for Clemente, I felt that when people hear Pirates they associate it with Stargell more often than Clemente.

[wags6817]

Not in Pittsburgh.

[Dr. Duran Duran]

Arizona- Luis Gonzalez
Atlanta- Hank Aaron
Chicago- Ernie Banks
Cincinati- Pete Rose
Colorado- Larry Walker
Florida- Luis Castillo
Houston- Jeff Bagwell
Dodgers- Sandy Koufax
Milwaukee- Robin Yount
New York Mets- Tom Seaver
Philadelphia- Mike Schmidt
Pittsburgh- Honus Wagner
St Louis- Stan Musial
San Diego- Tony Gwynn
San Francisco- Willie Mays
Washington- Vladimir Guererro

Baltimore- Cal Ripken Jr.
Boston- Ted Williams
Chicago White Sox- Frank Thomas (I want to say Luke Appling)
Cleveland- Bob Feller
Detroit- Ty Cobb
Kansas City- George Brett
Los Angeles/Anaheim- Nolan Ryan
Minnesota- Harmon Kilebrew
New York Yankees- Babe Ruth
Oakland- Jimmie Foxx
Seattle- Ken Griffey Jr.
Tampa Bay- Aubrey Huff
Texas- Ivan Rodriguez
Toronto- Carlos Delgado