
When I signed up with this forum.....I was told....
"always start your studs!"
and
"don't play anyone from Detroit!"
That takes care of one of your problems.....
{1} Toronto(ERA-4.85+whip-1.46)and Philly(ERA-3.80+ whip- 1.29)
vs....
{2}AZ (ERA- 3.97 + whip - 1.32 and Texas(ERA - 6.19 + whip-1.67)
1 = (Toronto + Philly).......4.32 ERA + whip -1.37
2 = (AZ + Tex)................5.08 ERA + whip - 1.48
Toronto = hitter's park
Texas = hitter's park
Ensberg faces much worse pitching staffs(AZ + tex)
Batista has more games in hitters park
good grief.....I haven't solved your problem.....flip a coin......

Fantasy sports are ruled by the 50-50-90 rule...
Anytime you have a 50-50 pick between two players, 90% of the time, you'll get it wrong!