Who are the top 24 fantasy players for 2006?

[nadacool]

So this is early and speculative, but what are everyone's top 24(essentially the first two rounds) fantasy baseball players. I'll start:

1. Alex Rodriguez (3B)
2. Albery Pujols (1B)
3. Vlad Guererro (OF)
4. Mark Teixeira (1B)
5. Jason Bay (OF)
6. Miguel Tejada (SS)
7. David Ortiz (DH)
8. Manny Ramirez (OF)
9. Johan Santana (SP)
10. Bobby Abreu (OF)
11. Carl Crawford (OF)
12. Miguel Cabrera (OF)
13. Derek Lee (1B)
14. Carlos Beltran (OF)
15. Andruw Jones (OF)
16. Barry Bonds (OF)
17. Alfonso Soriano (2B)
18. David Wright (3B)
19. Ichiro Suzuki (OF)
20. Michael Young (SS)
21. Mariano Rivera (RP)
22. Travis Hafner (1B)
23. Pedro Martinez (SP)
24. Gary Sheffield (OF)

[sublime8414]

1. Alex Rodriguez (3B)
2. Albery Pujols (1B)
3. Vlad Guererro (OF)
4. Mark Teixeira (1B)
5. David Ortiz (DH)
6. Manny Ramirez (OF)
7. Johan Santana (SP)
8. Jason Bay (OF)
9. Miguel Tejada (SS)
10. David Wright (3B)
11. Chase Utley (2b)
12. Bobby Abreu (OF)
13. Miguel Cabrera (OF)
14. Derek Lee (1B)
15. Carl Crawford (OF)
16. Lance Berkman (OF)
17. Roy Oswalt (SP)
18. Michael Young (SS)
19. Barry Bonds (OF)
20. Pedro Martinez (SP)
21. Chris Carpenter (SP)
22. Aramis Ramirez (3B)
23. Travis Hafner (1B)
24. Carlos Lee (OF)

[MrT]

5. Jason Bay (OF) ranked too high but within top 24
6. Miguel Tejada (SS) same comment
14. Carlos Beltran (OF) not top 24 based on 2005 numbers
22. Travis Hafner (1B) not in my top 24
23. Pedro Martinez (SP) " " " " "
24. Gary Sheffield (OF) ditto

[kentx12]

Bay dosent crack my top 10 and I think that you have Wright ranked way to low.

[The_Met_Threat]

Bay too high, Wright too low, i just skimmed through that.

[Red Stripe]

Move Wright up and Bay down

I'd also move Bonds down, I wouldn't be so sure of putting him in the top 24 already with him only playing about a sixth of a season last year and him being about 40 something years old.

[Thursday]

Michael Young too low. He's about 13 or 14, and if Tejada is going to be #6, Young isn't far behind.

[The_Met_Threat]

So this is early and speculative, but what are everyone's top 24(essentially the first two rounds) fantasy baseball players. I'll start:

1. Alex Rodriguez (3B)
2. Albery Pujols (1B)
3. Vlad Guererro (OF)
4. Mark Teixeira (1B)
5. Jason Bay (OF) - too high (around 10-14)
6. Miguel Tejada (SS) - should be around 10
7. David Ortiz (DH)
8. Manny Ramirez (OF)
9. Johan Santana (SP)
10. Bobby Abreu (OF)
11. Carl Crawford (OF)
12. Miguel Cabrera (OF)
13. Derek Lee (1B)
14. Carlos Beltran (OF) - a little too high
15. Andruw Jones (OF) - a little too high
16. Barry Bonds (OF) - a little too high
17. Alfonso Soriano (2B)
18. David Wright (3B) - too low (10-14)
19. Ichiro Suzuki (OF) - i wouldn't take ichiro second round
20. Michael Young (SS) - too low
21. Mariano Rivera (RP) - closer 2nd round? ummm no. i dont even think id take mo as the first closer, and the first closer shoould go round 5 or 6
22. Travis Hafner (1B) wouldnt take him second round / is he even eligible for 1b?
23. Pedro Martinez (SP)
24. Gary Sheffield (OF)

[bucksox]

1. Alex Rodriguez (3B)
2. Albert Pujols (1B)
3. Vlad Guererro (OF)
4. Mark Teixeira (1B)
5. David Ortiz (DH)
6. Manny Ramirez (OF)
7. Johan Santana (SP)
8. Bobby Abreu (OF)
9. Miguel Tejada (SS)
10. Chase Utley (2b)
11. Carlos Lee (OF)
12. Jason Bay(OF)
13. Miguel Cabrera (OF)
14. Derek Lee (1B)
15. Carl Crawford (OF)
16. Lance Berkman (OF)
17. Roy Oswalt (SP)
18. Michael Young (SS)
19. Barry Bonds (OF)
20. Pedro Martinez (SP)
21. Chris Carpenter (SP)
22. Aramis Ramirez (3B)
23. David Wright (3B)
24. Carlos Lee (OF)

[blacksox]

The Krause Publications experts league draft went like this (with Shandler, Poilot, Ambrosius, Funston, Cockroft, and others participating):

Alex Rodriguez (3B)
Albert Pujols (1B)
Vladimir Guerrero (OF)
Manny Ramirez (OF)
Johan Santana (P)
Mark Teixeira (1B)
Carl Crawford (OF)
David Ortiz (DH)
Miguel Cabrera (3B,OF)
Miguel Tejada (SS)
Derrek Lee (1B)
Bobby Abreu (OF)
David Wright (3B)
Jimmy Rollins (SS)
Ichiro Suzuki (OF)
Carlos Beltran (OF)
Jason Bay (OF)
Michael Young (SS)
Jose Reyes (SS)
Victor Martinez (C)
Todd Helton (1B)
Alfonso Soriano (2B)
Pedro Martinez (P)
Roy Oswalt (P)