Which player would you drop to add Byrnes?

[tjhksig]

[quote=]Bradly. Cleveland's lineup sux donkey balls.

A lineup has very little to do with player performance. Bradley just had 3 sb tonite, and is hitting.[/quote]

No offense, but I just read your posts in the thread concerning Jose Hernandez and Mark Bellhorn, and you say "runs and RBI's are team dependant". But now you totally contradict yourself????

[thehat]

Cat would be the drop. It's an easy call the way I see it.

[America4Americans]

drop millar. he doesn't even play everyday in boston's lineup. granted, he's a good hitter, but i'd drop him more than those other guys

[HOOTIE]

Lineup has a ton to do w/ runs and RBI's. I'd rather have Cat and him getting knocked in all the time by Delgado and Wells, than Bradley trying for a inside the park homer everytime in order to score.

Sure, lineups effect team dependent stats like runs and rbis, but they have little effect on actual player performance, like oba and slugging %. Its not my theory. Bill James found that lineups have a small effect on performance. Basically means if your good, your stats will show it, and if your bad, it will show.

[HOOTIE]

No offense, but I just read your posts in the thread concerning Jose Hernandez and Mark Bellhorn, and you say "runs and RBI's are team dependant". But now you totally contradict yourself????

Non taken. Yes, runs and rbis are team dependent. But i think you are equating runs and rbis as player performance? Those 2 stats have to be separated? I'm talking players performance dependent on himself, and his park, like average, oba, slugging %, runs created, ops.

[eftda]

wait what league are you in...?

i think your in mine

but nm DROP SHEFF!!!!

lol, um drop frank hes not that good

[quickfingerz]

None...